• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • All Posts
  • About

Colorfully Classic

  • Ways to Wear
  • Vintage Styling
  • Style Finds
  • Outfits
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Styling a Lilly Pulitzer Dress to Feel Less Preppy

August 14, 2025Ways to Wear
Lilly Pulitzer dress (similar), Vintage lace coat (similar one on Etsy), Maryam Nassir Zadeh sandals (similar)

You don’t see Lilly Pulitzer much in San Francisco, if at all. It seems to remain a staple for towns with preppier roots. Growing up on the east coast, I still have at least two Lilly dresses in my wardrobe (plus an archive of many more at my parents house in Florida). I rarely wear them but once in a while I find one I really like and get it.

Over the last decade, I’ve become a lot less preppy. My early 20s were very preppy. But as I’ve gotten older, I now lean towards a mix of simplicity and vintage whimsy. Yet, some traces of those preppy roots have stuck with me.

I’ve always loved the original Lilly Pulitzer photos from when she first started making her dresses in the 50s. So, this past year as I’ve really leaned into 50s and 60s vintage to inspire my everyday style, it dawned on me to use these vintage photos to give new life into my Lilly dresses I never wear but still very much love.

(Also, this is not a sponsored post, just some thoughts on style ideas for something that lives outside of your style aesthetic but something you still want to wear.)

So here are three ways I’ve been wearing a usually preppy dress in less preppy feeling ways!

What better way to create a vintage inspired look than to add some actual vintage. This 60s lace jacket came with its matching shift dress in the same color (one of my favorites!) which happens to perfectly pair with the blue of this Lilly Pulitzer dress. I found a similar one here in a gorgeous light green color.

I added a more modern and simple block heel. Mine are old but this similar pair is so cute.

Straw hat (similar), Sandgrens clogs, Etsy shell necklace

For this outfit, an easy clog felt less predictable but still simple and more minimalist. Then a summery straw hat and shell necklace for a whimsical touch. It feels here more like a vintage printed shift despite being new.

Huaraches (similar), Silk scarves (shop here)

A silk scarf as a belt is a great way to break up the busy, bright patterns. And a beach-y huarache for a more masculine touch. Bringing down the super girly-ness of the pattern.

From what I’ve been trying out, it seems a non-traditionally preppy shoe and more bold, playful accessories make all the difference. Like a good leather huarache and a simple silk scarf. I still love a pair of Jack Rogers with Lilly Pulitzer dresses on occasion, but now I prefer a more vintage, quirky approach!

Which style is your favorite?

Mary

Previous Post: « Whimsical and Practical Summer Clutches
Next Post: Easy Flats to Wear Everyday »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Colorfully Classic is a place for building a wearable and (mostly) practical wardrobe for all occasions. From practical every day looks to vintage and whimsical finds.

Categories

  • Outfits
  • Sewing
  • Style Finds
  • Ways to Wear

Featured Post

STRAW & RATTAN BAGS FOR SUMMER

Footer

Categories

  • Outfits
  • Sewing
  • Style Finds
  • Ways to Wear

Search

Copyright © 2025 ⸱ Colorfully Classic ⸱ Design by Love & Riot

Copyright © 2025 · Dainty on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in